DoorDash vs. Uber Eats: Which Pays More?
No app pays more for everyone. Learn how DoorDash and Uber Eats pay differently and how to run a two-week test to find which one pays you more.
Drivers argue about this constantly, and the honest answer is that it depends on your city, your hours and the offers you take. An app that pays well in one market can be slow in another. The better question is which one pays you more after your costs. You can answer that with a short test.
How the two pay structures differ
Both apps build your pay from base pay or fares, promotions and tips, and both say drivers keep 100% of tips. The differences are in how the base is calculated.
- DoorDash offers two earning modes. Earn per Offer pays a set amount for each offer, based on its time, distance and desirability. Earn by Time pays a minimum guaranteed hourly rate for active time.
- Uber Eats calculates fares from the anticipated time and effort of each delivery plus real-time factors in your area, and it offers optional promotions such as Quests. In some markets it also has a minimum earnings guarantee for time spent on trips.
Rules and rates change by city, so check what your own apps show.
Run a two-week test
- Choose a similar set of hours for each app, such as two weeks of weekday dinners on one and two weeks on the other. Keep the days and times as comparable as you can.
- For each period, record your earnings, hours and miles. Include the waiting time.
- Enter each one in the delivery profit calculator with the same MPG, gas price and wear cost.
- Compare profit per hour and profit per mile, not earnings.
Here is an example with made-up numbers, using a 25 MPG car, gas at $3.20 and a 12 cent wear cost.
| App A | App B | |
|---|---|---|
| Earnings | $540 | $480 |
| Hours | 22 | 20 |
| Miles | 410 | 300 |
| Fuel and car wear | $101.68 | $74.40 |
| Profit | $438.32 | $405.60 |
| Earnings per hour | $24.55 | $24.00 |
| Profit per hour | $19.92 | $20.28 |
App A looks better on earnings per hour. App B wins on profit per hour because it needed 110 fewer miles. This is why comparing apps by what they show on the screen can lead you to the wrong answer.
Other things worth tracking
- How much of your earnings come from promotions you may not always get
- How long you wait between offers
- Which app sends you farther unpaid drives
- How your tips compare
Using both apps
Many drivers use more than one app. Check the terms of each platform on running them at the same time and on how that affects acceptance and ratings. If you do use both, record your hours and miles for each separately, or the comparison will not be meaningful.
When one app is clearly ahead for your hours, shift more time to it. Retest every few months, since promotions and demand change.